When you make cheese yourself, there's nothing in it but wholesome ingredients. No texturizers, flavor "enhancers," or coloring.
Neufchâtel is a basic, creamy cheese that is a mainstay in cooking and is delicious all by itself. It's made from fresh, whole milk with very little rennet and a long curdling time. When fresh it resembles cream cheese, but aging brings out a pungent aroma and a stronger taste so you can use it mild or tangy. The step-by-step method for making homemade cheese follows.
1. Sterilize all utensils and bowls that the milk or cheese will touch. Place a gallon of milk in the top of a double boiler (or similar arrangement) and heat to 84-86°F. Stir in 4 tablespoons of fresh cultured buttermilk.
2. Use half the rennet recommended for a gallon of milk. Dissolve the rennet in two tablespoons cool water and stir half of this solution into the milk. Hold the temperature as close to 85°F as possible for 16-18 hours, the time needed for the milk to coagulate.
3. Place a colander over a deep pot and line with muslin—ordinary cheesecloth is too coarse for the runny curd. The muslin should be boiled previously for 5 minutes. When the milk is coagulated, pour the curds and whey into the colander and allow it to drain for 2 hours. Tie the corners of the muslin together so the curds can't leak out.
4. Surround the bag of curd with ice until thoroughly chilled.
5. Place the chilled curd on a board and put another board on top of it. Place two bricks on top for weight. Set the whole thing in a cake pan and place in the refrigerator for 8 hours.
6. Remove the curd from the bag into a mixing bowl. Add 1½ teaspoons of salt and knead it into the curd with your hands, breaking up any large lumps.
7. Here's an easy cheese press you can make. It should be sterilized before use. It consists of a can with both ends cleanly off, and two wooden discs that just fit the can, each with several holes for whey to escape.
8. Cut two muslin squares an inch larger than the wooden discs. Place a disc on a wire rack, cover with one piece of muslin, and press the can down over them. The edges of the muslin should be hanging out. Spoon the salted curd into the press and cover with the other piece of muslin. Place the second disc in to the press and firmly press down. Sit a sturdy jar in the top end, place a brick on top and put the whole arrangement in a cake pan to catch drippings. Place in refrigerator for 48 hours.
9. Pry out the lower disc, peel off the cloth, and push the cheese from the other end.
10. Rub salt lightly on the outside of the cheese and allow to dry at room temperature for 24 hours. Then eat fresh or place in your refrigerator for 3 or 4 weeks, or until you like the flavor. Trim any mold that might develop. This cheese needs refrigeration.
Find rennet and other cheese-making supplies at cheesemaking.com.